USDA Proposes New Horse Soring Rules and Drops 2024 Pad Ban Plan; Comments Close December 14
WASHINGTON, D.C. — Proposed rule published in the Federal Register on November 13, 2026; public comments accepted through December 14, 2026.
The U.S. Department of Agriculture has proposed a new set of Horse Protection Act rules that would formally withdraw what remains of its 2024 overhaul, including the plan to replace industry-licensed inspectors, while adding blood tests, limb swabs and a ban on drugs that hide signs of soring. The public has until December 14 to comment.

The Tennessee Walking Horse National Celebration, photographed in 2013. Illustrative photo, not taken in connection with the proposed rule. Photo: Randall R. Saxton / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0.
Soring is the deliberate injury of a horse's front legs or hooves, using caustic chemicals, cuts or devices, so the pain makes the animal lift its feet higher. It has been linked mainly to Tennessee Walking Horses and racking horses and the exaggerated show gait known as the "big lick." The Horse Protection Act has banned showing, selling or transporting sore horses since 1970.
The proposal from USDA's Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service (APHIS) follows a long legal fight. In May 2024, APHIS finalized a rule that would have banned action devices and non-therapeutic pads on Tennessee Walking Horses and racking horses, and replaced the inspectors that horse industry groups train and license, called Designated Qualified Persons (DQPs), with inspectors trained and authorized by APHIS. On January 31, 2025, a federal court in the Northern District of Texas vacated the device, pad and substance bans, the rule's new skin-lesion standard and its appeal procedures. The court upheld the switch to APHIS-authorized inspectors, but the agency postponed the remaining provisions several times, most recently to December 31, 2026.
APHIS now says the court's decision left an "unworkable patchwork" and that Congress did not raise the program's budget to pay for the new inspector system. A House Appropriations Committee report had also directed the agency to withdraw the 2024 rule. Under the new proposal, industry-licensed DQPs would stay, but with stricter screening for conflicts of interest and training and evaluation by experienced equine veterinarians.
The main changes APHIS proposes include:
- A ban on masking agents, such as sedatives and topical numbing products, that can hide signs of soring during inspection.
- Pastern swabs and blood samples collected under each certified inspection program's procedures.
- Removal of the "scar rule," which a court found likely exceeds USDA's authority.
- Two APHIS veterinarians must independently agree before a horse is reported as noncompliant, and owners could appeal on the spot to a neutral Appeals Official.
- A sore horse would be disqualified only from the class in which it was inspected, not from the whole show.
APHIS acknowledges that this last change could lead some exhibitors to use more drugs to get a horse through inspection later in the same event, and says the masking-agent ban and testing are meant to counter that.
Beyond the Headlines
The agency's own record explains why testing matters. The proposal cites APHIS blood samples from 80 horses at six shows in 2015, of which 20 percent tested positive for sedatives or anti-inflammatory drugs. It also says APHIS staff have recently seen more horses showing signs of sedation and have found syringes and prohibited substances in warm-up areas.
What the proposal does not do matters as well. It would not bring back the 2024 ban on pads and action devices, which the court struck down. A Congressional Research Service report from August 2026 also notes that APHIS found higher noncompliance rates in its own inspections than in inspections done only by DQPs from 2017 to 2022, which was the reason the 2024 rule moved away from industry inspectors. The House committee, for its part, had asked APHIS to work with the industry on an objective, science-based inspection system. We had not found published reactions from welfare groups or veterinary associations to this specific proposal when this story was prepared.
Anyone can comment, including owners of other breeds. Go to Regulations.gov and search for docket APHIS-2026-0067. APHIS notes that all comments become part of the public record. Previous NEWS coverage of horse health includes the recall of hay cubes after horse deaths in Utah, Nevada and Arizona. If you want to mark the season in a calmer way, our guide to National Day of the Horse on December 13 suggests practical ways to support horse welfare.
Sources & further reading
- Federal Register — Horse Protection, proposed rule, Docket No. APHIS-2026-0067 (91 FR 73380, November 13, 2026).
- USDA APHIS — 2026 Horse Protection Proposed Rule: questions and answers and how to comment.
- Congressional Research Service — The Horse Protection Act: Background and Considerations for Congress (R49325, August 2026).
- American Farriers Journal — U.S. Department of Agriculture Opens Comments to Amend the Horse Protection Act (November 12, 2026).


